[[ books pdf ]] Starn, O: Shining Path - Love, Madness, and Revolution in th Autor Orin Starn – Paydayloansnsi.co.uk

Starn, O: Shining Path - Love, Madness, and Revolution in th For all its enormity the spectacular death toll, the seismic political shifts it caused in Peru, its legacy stamped on the city of Lima , the story of the Shining Path s rise to prominence and the war that followed is little known outside of the region and the outsiders who care about the Andes.Starn and La Serna have brought this history to wider audiences with meticulous research, thoughtful and generous analysis, and an engaging, suspenseful writing style As a student of the Andes been going there since the mid 1990s and have written about the history of Peru , I can t endorse this book enough The detractors can say what they will about the portrayal of communist ideology in the book it s amazingly balanced and quibble with extremely minor errors or what are perceived as errors what book doesn t have them The Shining Path will still become one of a handful of definitive, yet accessible, histories of this fascinating, sad, and frankly bizarre chapter of Peru s history. I thought i d love this book The subject is fascinating, the characters intriguing, and like a good novel it claims to know intimate details of their lives and even thoughts.But then I started to notice sloppy errors, large and small, on page after page The authors seem so dismissive of their subjects communist passions that they don t even bother to get simple facts straight.No, maoists around the world didn t read Peking Daily , they read Peking Review No, the Sendero ideology wasn t called Leninist Marxist Maoist Thought , it was called Marxism Leninism Maoism, and eventually Gonzalo Thought No, Angela Davis wasn t a Communist like them but exactly the kind of pro Soviet cadre that the Sendero considered counter revolutionary.More significant is the authors sloppy distortion of key ideas.One example among many Their Marxist orthodoxy taught that modern day sexist oppression originated with capitalism a view famously advanced by Friedrich Engels in The Origins of the Family That crams three errors into one sentence Engels situated the origin of male supremacy at the dawn of private property, not with capitalism which came 10,000 years later The Sendero situated Peruvian male supremacy in semifeudal, semicolonial society not in generic capitalism And finally, the authors don t even bother to get the name of Engels famous book right.After a while, such errors page after page made me question the credibility of the authors Their sloppy condescension toward the ideas of this movement which was so defined by its highly articulated ideology made me suspect that their treatment of complex events was probably also unreliable and distorted.They must think their subjects ideas aren t worth documenting accurately And they must assume readers like us are too uninformed to notice.After a few chapters, I just didn t trust them any. This is one of the most disappointing books I have read in a while given the fascinating subject.Initially I was impressed by the readable and accessible tone of the authors obviously aimed at a general audience Indeed, that accessibility is probably the strong point here for anyone wanting to learn about the Shining Path Unfortunately, I think you would also get a picture simplified to the point of distortion.Perhaps the most interesting thing about the Shining Path is understanding how so many people were convinced to commit horrific acts of violence and almost gleefully sacrifice their own lives for what from the outside seemed like a movement so out of time and place The best works on Shining Path thus explain the movement s highly developed ideology and the role it played in sustaining a movement that against all odds spread across Peru from Ayacucho and brought the war to Lima over a 12 year period.These authors, however, seem so at pains to signal their own distaste for anything to do with communism that Sendero s ideology is dismissively simplified and treated with a tone of almost eye rolling irony throughout the book Beyond a general acknowledgement of poverty, the reader is left with a picture of gullible students following a faintly ridiculous leader with delusions of grandeur The authors also briefly mention the existence of pro Shining Path villages However, readers are left to puzzle why any village ever supported the group when all the Shining Path cadres ever seemed to do was march out of the mountains from time to time to harangue villagers with political dogma and inflict unspeakable violence upon them.The book is probably ok for readers wishing to get an introduction to what happened during the Shining Path s war in Peru However, it s not great for really understanding why any of it happened I would therefore encourage people to look beyond this one to the many fine books on the subject by Carlos Iv n Degregori, Steve Stern, and others. wish that Latin Americanists were publishing work this good This account of the Shining Path terrorist group, from its birth to its end, has long been overdue It has many details gathered from the victims and the participants Like most individuals who ultimately become dictators, the leaders of the group were out and out psychotics. I couldn t see where the madness in the Shining Path was Wanting to bring about a fairer, equal, society in Peru was surely the sane thing to do Any insanity was in the mass murders, rapes and disappearances by the Peruvian state authorities. On May on the eve of Peru s presidential election, five masked men stormed a small town in the Andean heartland They set election ballots ablaze and vanished into the night, but not before planting a red hammer and sickle banner in the town square The lone man arrested the next morning later swore allegiance to a group called Shining Path The tale of how this ferocious group of guerrilla insurgents launched a decade long reign of terror, and how brave police investigators and journalists brought it to justice, may be the most compelling chapter in modern Latin American history, but the full story has never been toldDescribed by a US State Department cable as cold blooded and bestial, Shining Path orchestrated bombings, assassinations, and massacres across the cities, countryside, and jungles of Peru in a murderous campaign to seize power and impose a Communist government At its helm was the professor turned revolutionary Abimael Guzm n, who launched his single minded insurrection alongside two women his charismatic young wife, Augusta La Torre, and the formidable Elena Iparraguirre, who married Guzm n soon after Augusta s mysterious death Their fanatical devotion to an outmoded and dogmatic ideology, and the military s bloody response, led to the death of nearly , PeruviansThe Shining Path

About the Author: Orin Starn

Is a well known author, some of his books are a fascination for readers like in the Starn, O: Shining Path Love, Madness, and Revolution in th book, this is one of the most wanted Orin Starn author readers around the world.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe US Now